
The world can have non-Chinese rare earths — for a price
Here’s what I thought I knew about rare earths: One, they’re important. (They’re in our smartphones! We can’t live without smartphones!) Two, they’re rare. Three, they come mostly from China, which mines and processes them in ways that are both dirty and ethically problematic.
They’re certainly important: They’re needed not just in phones but in cars, semiconductors, medical imaging chemicals, robots, offshore wind turbines and a wide range of military hardware.
But it turns out they’re not all that rare: They can be found all over the world. They’re just very spread out and hard to refine.
And as it happens, the world doesn’t have to depend on China for them either. As I learned from reading two stories about rare earths by my colleagues this past week — one from China and one from France — relying on China for these strategically important resources was a choice: For Western countries, it outsourced pollution; for everyone, it kept production costs down.
But rare earths could be produced differently. They could be cleaner. They could come from non-Chinese sources. All of this, however, has a price tag attached.
Baotou vs. La Rochelle
This year, my colleague Keith Bradsher traveled to Baotou, a flat, industrial city of two million people in the Inner Mongolia region of China that calls itself the world capital of the rare earth industry. While the air in Baotou no longer has the acrid, faintly metallic taste that he found during a 2010 visit, a huge lake of toxic and radioactive waste has not been cleaned up. He also traveled to Longnan, in south-central China, another town that produces rare earths. There, he found a creek in front of some mines that was, as he put it, “bright orange and bubbling mysteriously.”
Contrast these scenes with the warehouse my colleague Jeanna Smialek visited in La Rochelle, a picturesque port city that has long ranked among the most livable places in France. A new rare-earths production line there takes recycled materials and, using “giant metal tanks topped by gently whirring motors,” distills out two key minerals used in magnets. (Fun fact: Rare earth magnets can be 15 times as powerful as iron magnets of the same weight.)
The catch? It costs about 20 percent more than importing the rare earths directly from China.

Lower cost, higher risk
Importing cheap Chinese rare earths comes with big risks. In April, in response to President Trump’s tariffs, China temporarily suspended almost all exports of seven kinds of rare-earth metals, as well as some of the very powerful magnets made from them.
The resulting shortages at car plants in the U.S. and Europe — a Ford Explorer factory in Chicago had to close temporarily — brought home the real cost of outsourcing these strategic minerals.
So the question is: Are countries prepared to shell out more, not just for cleaner rare earths, but also for their own strategic independence?
It’s not clear that the answer is yes. Europe has, for example, long relied on cheap Russian gas and avoided investing in military deterrence. And even though China first cut off rare earth supplies to Japan in 2010, few countries have since taken meaningful steps to diversify.
But reading these two pieces together, it’s hard not to be struck by the stark contrast between two different versions of the same industry. Rare earth production can be relatively clean. It doesn’t have to be the near-exclusive domain of a country that weaponizes its industry dominance. But this sort of rare earth would be more expensive. Is anyone willing to pay?
| MORE TOP NEWS |

| Ukraine: Trump said he was “not happy” with President Vladimir Putin, whom he accused of “killing too many people.” In Kyiv, Trump’s announcement that the U.S. would send more military aid was welcomed, but some were skeptical. Texas: At least 161 people in Kerr County are still missing, according to the governor. No one has been found alive there since Friday, officials said. Here’s the latest. Gaza: Israel and Hamas wrangled over the terms of a cease-fire deal for Gaza, but there was no sign of an imminent breakthrough. Trade: Asian countries largely built their economies to supply the West. Trump’s new tariff threats amounted to a declaration that the relationship must change. Weather: After a blistering heat wave, wildfires are burning in Spain and France. Afghanistan: Judges at the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Taliban leaders, citing restrictions on women and girls as evidence of crimes against humanity. |
| London: A British criminal gang was hired by Russian operatives to kidnap the Russian owner of Hide, a Michelin-starred restaurant. Myanmar: An army corporal was seized outside his base. He expected the worst. Instead, he saw his little brother standing among the rebels on the other side of the civil war. |
| SPORTS NEWS |

| Tennis: We’re in the quarterfinals at Wimbledon. Carlos Alcaraz and Aryna Sabalenka have both advanced to the next round. Follow live updates. Cycling: Tadej Pogacar claimed his 100th stage win, beating Mathieu van der Poel and Jonas Vingegaard on Day 4 of the Tour de France. Soccer: The Spanish authorities have released initial findings regarding the car crash that killed the Liverpool striker Diogo Jota and his brother. |
| MORNING READ |

New York City’s ultrarich are headed to the Hamptons for the summer, where high-end grocery stores are adding new items — and higher prices — to their shelves. Forget $100 lobsters — how about a melon from Japan that sells for as much as $400?
Shop owners admit there’s some rivalry in the race to serve a wealthy clientele.
| CONVERSATION STARTERS |

| Art Zoo: A giant T. rex fossil and a huge denim gorilla are just two of the curiosities at a new museum in Amsterdam. Robot recruiter: You might have thought A.I. was coming for your job. First, it’s coming for your job interviewer. Valery Gergiev: The star maestro, who has been shunned in the West for his ties to Vladimir Putin, will conduct in Italy. |
| ARTS AND IDEAS |

Sweden’s secret to well-being
Stina Larsson, 98, has tended a garden in Stockholm for more than 40 years. It’s one of more than 7,000 garden allotments, known as koloniträdgårdar, that give residents a sanctuary where they can trade pavement for soil and buzzing traffic for birdsong.
Rising interest in these urban gardens, particularly among younger Swedes, has led to an increase in prices for the plots in recent years, and the demand far outpaces the supply. Read more.
| RECOMMENDATIONS |

Cook: This comforting ground-chicken dish is layered with typical Desi spices.